Should Polygamy Be Legal?

Polygamy is currently illegal in all 50 states, but should it be? Polygamous lifestyles often carry with them the stereotypes of incest, subordination, and abuse, but as exemplified in TLC’s show “Sister Wives” this is not true of all polygamous families.  The stars of “Sister Wives,” Kody Brown and his four wives, are currently challenging the constitutionality of the Utah state law banning polygamous marriages as violating their rights under the due process and equal protection clause of the 14th Amendment. The Browns are concurrently coming out to America on their new reality TV show as a polygamous family trying to prove how happy, healthy, and safe their lifestyle choice is.

The hot topic of marriage equality is currently consumed with the same sex marriage debate, but perhaps, as Americans are expanding their understanding of marriage as not just between one man and one women, the discussion should be further opened up to the idea of one man and multiple women. The Brown family is trying to bring new information to anti-polygamists minds, by proving that they live in a workable loving family environment.

Polygamous activists have a long way to come in changing the minds of Americans to view polygamous families as a plausible lifestyle choice. Many people rightfully question whether the children and wives in polygamous families are getting enough attention from one man. Kody Brown is currently the father of 17 children. How is it possible to give each child enough love and attention when there are 16 other children and 4 wives pinning for his attention? Is there too much pressure on one man to provide for a family of 22? Or do these families have the right idea of having four mommies? Jealousy is a common problem in these large families, but it is one that each of these adults have chosen to be a part of.  Should the courts then just stay out of their private adult decisions?

One thought on “Should Polygamy Be Legal?

  1. Yes, an adult should be free to share love, sex, residence, and marriage with any consenting adults.

    With polygamy, some say “It will be a legal/paperwork nightmare as our system is set up for couples.” That’s what the bigots said about same-sex marriage and the Americans With Disabilities Act and just about any civil rights laws. Of course it is easier for those who already have what they want to keep things as they are. But what about all of the people who are denied their rights?

    Some say “What about child custody and child support?” What about children from one night stands, donated sperm, surrogate mothers, affairs, brief flings, or supposedly monogamous marriage that’s ending? What about children born to a woman whose husband wasn’t the man who impregnated her? All of these situations are entirely legal. A court decides custody disputes that aren’t resolved amicably.

Comments are closed.